Scotch Oysters

Scotch Oysters

My wife and I were at a new-to-the-area market yesterday called Earth Fare. For the most part, I prefer Dorothy Lane Market, but Earth Fare does have a great salad bar. It’s just a bit too health-foody for me, I guess. Anyway, they have lots of bulk tofu and bark and seeds and hippy stuff, but also have nice seafood, wine and deli departments. They just happened to have oysters in the shell, so I picked up a few of them to try on the grill.

I don’t typically grill oysters, as my wife doesn’t care for them much, but I thought it would be fun to try something out… When I told her what I was doing, she wanted no part of it, anyway! I decided to try something out with whisky, as I keep looking for ways to incorporate whisky into different foods. So I was already ensuring that my wife wasn’t going to be a part of my little experiment. I then threw in some bleu cheese, clinching the deal… These were all for me.

To start things off, I got my Big Green Egg fired up with a 2 zone fire (hot on one side, no coals on the other). This can only be done on an XL, as the firebox on smaller BGEs is not large enough. I was going to actually try this on the Infrared, but a very small mouse decided to try out the grate as a summer cottage. I discouraged that by adding a lot of heat (with the mouse gone), but I want to be sure he’s found other living quarters prior to firing that up to cook on it!

Grilling Scotch Oysters

As the BGE was warming up, I melted some butter in a sauce pan, browning it a bit, then added some Ardbeg 10-year-old whisky and a bit of fresh tarragon and salt and pepper. The oysters went over the hot part of the grill for about 2 minutes, just until the shells started to open. I’m daring and all, but I don’t own a shucking knife, and I didn’t want to chance gouging my hand opening up oysters with a screwdriver or paring knife. Once the shells opened a bit, it was easy to remove the flat half of the shell.

Scotch Oyste

The oysters went back onto the grill, but this time I placed them away from the direct heat. I added the butter/whisky/tarragon, then topped them with some bleu d’Aurvergne cheese, a really creamy bleu cheese. I closed the lid and let them oysters cook in the butter and whisky for about 5 minutes, then removed them when the edges of the butter started browning on the shell a bit.

Grilled Scotch Oysters

The oysters went right to the table for me to try. The verdict? I think my plate says it all…


I will warn that these are pretty strong flavors. If you aren’t into peaty whisky or bleu cheese, you can swap a lighter version of each. I might try something like Old Pulteney or Highland Park, or even a Glenmorangie, and smoked gouda might be a nice addition for the cheese. In my book, though, I really liked the in-your-face flavors; each oyster is a small bite of big tastes, and worth grilling again! I love experiments that turn out to be keepers. I do want to try some other grilled oysters to come up with an oyster medley… Any suggestions?

A couple side notes… I “typed” this up on my new Xyboard tablet (thanks to Verizon Wireless), using a stylus with handwriting recognition instead of a keyboard. I really like the way this works, and the word recognition is really strong. This is a great way of writing on a tablet that I find easier than screen-typing on a keyboard. Another item: I added a recipe plug in to allow printing of recipes. Let me know what you think.

Disclosure: I am participating in the Verizon Wireless Midwest Savvy Gourmets program and have been provided with a wireless device and six months of service in exchange for my honest opinions about the product.



4.5 from 2 reviews
Scotch Oysters
Grilled oysters with butter, whiskey, tarragon and bleu cheese
Recipe type: Seafood Appetizer
Serves: 2-3
Prep time: 
Cook time: 
Total time: 
  • 6 in-the-shell raw oysters (fresh)
  • ½ stick butter
  • 2 ounces Scotch whisky
  • 2 tsp fresh tarragon
  • 1 ounce bleu cheese
  • salt and pepper to taste
  1. Prepare oven for indirect cooking. On a gas grill, add wood chunks to give some smoke flavor. On a charcoal grill, the charcoal will give enough wood flavor.
  2. In a saucepan, melt the butter and brown slightly.
  3. Remove the saucepan from the heat and add the whisky, returning the pan to a medium-low heat, being careful not to let the mixture bubble over.
  4. When the bubbling subsides, remove the butter and whisky from heat and add the tarragon, salt and pepper. Set this aside.
  5. Place the oysters over the direct heat on the grill until the shells just begin to open (about 2 minutes).
  6. Remove the flat half of the shell, and return the oysters, in the curved half of the shell, back to the grate, but not over the direct heat this time. (Place oysters shell-side down).
  7. Add butter/whisky/tarragon to the oysters evenly, and top with the bleu cheese.
  8. Close the grill and cook for approximately 5 more minutes, until the butter just starts to brown along the shell.
  9. Remove and serve immediately.
I like peaty whiskies, so I used Ardbeg. Highland Park or Old Pulteney would also work well. An alternative to Ardbeg that's cheaper and still very good is Black Bottle blended whisky. Instead of bleu cheese (I used d'Aurvergne), a milder cheese can be used, also, such as gouda or a mild cheddar. Instead of tarragon, a dash of hot sauce can be added.

About Curt McAdams

I guess I'm a bit of a foodie, learning to cook from my mom, then getting obsessed with outdoor cooking, competition barbecue, bread baking and just about all things food. Lately, I've been trying to upgrade my photography skills a bit, though I still have a long way to go.


  1. The handwriting recognition is great! I need to remember to carry my stylus around with me more. Wish it had a storage place for it.

    I don’t do oysters, so no comment from me on the recipe :) Pics look great, though
    Paula @ Frosted Fingers recently posted..Homemade Chinese nightMy Profile

    • Paula, you sound like my wife… But that just leaves more for me!

      I know what you mean for storing the stylus; it would be great if the cover had some sort of spot to clip it or slide it in.
      Curt recently posted..Scotch OystersMy Profile

  2. These flavors ares some of my favorites.Thank you for the stylus types. I plan to experimnet.

  3. I have never had grilled oysters like that but they look absolutely delicious. I like the combination of ingredients that you chose.

    • Sarah,

      Thanks for the compliment, and for visiting. I’m going to try one more variation on this… I’m going to add the whisky after cooked, then light them on fire… Should look really cool! I’m also going to try them with a cumin/lime vinaigrette, ten an olive tapenade/vodka mix. I loved doing these on the grill!

  4. These look incredible, Curt. I’ve learned that I love raw oysters and do not love fried oysters; love this “in between” preparation method. And you even managed to work in two of my other favorite ingredients: blue cheese and Scotch. :) My new Weber gets delivered next week and this will be on the top of my list of recipes to try!

    • Kristen,

      The texture of these isn’t like raw, but they don’t have all that breaking on them of Fred oysters. Do a 2 zone fire with te Weber to give sace to get away from direct heat!

  5. I wish my tablet had that handwriting feature.
    Chris recently posted..Ribs Smoked On a Gas GrillMy Profile

  6. I love all of those ingredients. The combo sounds wonderful. I am going to give these a try. I love grilling oysters, this is just a different spin…

    Thanks for the idea!


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

Rate this recipe:  

CommentLuv badge

Pin It on Pinterest

Share This

Share This

Share this post with your friends!

%d bloggers like this: