A New Whisky

If you’ve been around Livefire much, you may know that I’m a fan of Scotch whisky, especially those from Islay (pronounced something with a long I, then luh, not lay). I’m a fan of Lagavulin, own a square foot of the island thanks to being a Friend of Laphroaig, and am on the Ardbeg Committee.

Ardbeg sign

Being on the Ardbeg Committee brought to me an invitation to a tasting of the aforementioned “new” whisky, Ardbeg Alligator. I immediately RSVP’ed for my wife and me to attend, even though it was on a school night! The event was in Cincy, at Nicholson’s Gastropub, right downtown.

Fountain Square

We got there a bit early, so we walked around Fountain Square a bit. There were a few ice skaters, and the tree was lit. The square is very nice around Christmas, but it was a bit cold, so we didn’t stay too long.

Fountain Square

Cincy Fountain Square

Fountain Square Ice Skating

Fountain Square

Cincy's Fountain Square

Back to Nicholson’s, we got a booth after signing in. We were given tickets for 3 drinks each. The good thing for me here is that my wife doesn’t care for whisky at all, so they were really all for me! This included, for each of us, a dram of Ardbeg 10 year old, followed by our choice of a Smoquito (mojito), a Smoquarita (margarita) or a Bloody Mary (with Ardbeg instead of vodka). This was followed by a dram each of Ardbeg Alligator. There were also free appetizers… All this for the grand price of FREE!

The pub is a great place, with a nice menu. I’ve never been unhappy with a meal there, and I like the ale and whisky selection. Jacob, our waiter, was great!

Nicholson's Jacob


Starting with the dram of the 10 year old, Ardbeg starts off great. It’s peaty, salty, seaweedy, sweet and delicious. It was served with a side of spring water in case it was wanted; I added a few drops to open up the whisky.

Glasses for Ardbeg

Ardbeg 10 yo

For the cocktails, I got a Bloody Mary, and my wife got the Smoquito, which was made with mint and brown sugar. The Bloody Mary was good, but their mix is a bit hotter than I really like; I prefer more of a horseradish heat than just hot sauce. It was good, though. The Smoquito was much better than I expected, though the brown sugar was a bit too much, but the Ardbeg went really nicely with it.

Ardbeg Smoquito


Then on to the Alligator. The difference in this is that it’s a single malt that blends the regular 10 year old with whisky from first use oak barrels that are highly charred (hence the Alligator name). It ends up being an odd mix of Scotch and Bourbon, kind of landing in between. It’s really nice, and definitely worth trying if you get a chance.


Did I really like it, though? Well, I got the last bottle left in Dayton, it seems, so, yes, I liked it. I wanted for a couple of reasons. First, friends that say they like bourbon but not Scotch can try this as a “gateway” Scotch. Second, I think it will make a great mint julep instead of using bourbon.

Alligator at Ardbeg Tasting

Ardbeg Alligator on my table

Alligator won’t replace Supernova or my Lagavulin, but it’s well worth having!

About Curt McAdams

I guess I'm a bit of a foodie, learning to cook from my mom, then getting obsessed with outdoor cooking, competition barbecue, bread baking and just about all things food. Lately, I've been trying to upgrade my photography skills a bit, though I still have a long way to go.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

CommentLuv badge

Pin It on Pinterest

Share This

Share This

Share this post with your friends!

%d bloggers like this: