In the last several months, a couple of places have opened up in the Dayton, Ohio, area that make fast food burgers. However, they’re not your typical burger.
The first one of the 2 chains I tried was Five Guys, and they make a really nice burger. Their catch is that you can get all kinds of great toppings (grilled onion, A1 sauce, bbq, sauce, mushrooms, etc) at no extra cost, and their fries are fresh cut and great.
Last week, my wife and I tried Smashburger, and I’ve got to say that, though I like Five Guys, Smashburger is the best fast-foodish chain burger I’ve had.
Smashburger isn’t all that big yet, though they do have franchises in several states. Their thing is localizing the burger joint a little bit by offering a regional style burger and carrying one or two local beers/ales. The atmosphere is modern and casual, and, like most fast food places, you get in line to place your order.
What’s different is that you can get wine and/or beer with your burger and you don’t have to pick up a tray to take it to a table; they have staff that takes care of bringing your meal to you.
I got a Buckeye Burger, which included fried peppers and Haystack onions, cheddar cheese (comes with American, but I switched), pickle, mayo, lettuce and tomato. I also got Smashfries, which are fries seasoned with rosemary, olive oil and garlic. My wife got a Smashburger without cheese with a side of Haystack onions, which are very thinly cut onion rings.
The fries and rings were the first thing we tried, and both were great. I love rosemary with potatoes, and it’s also great with fries (and not overdone). The rings had a nice amount of batter and were really good, too.
Then the burger. I got a half pound burger, while my wife got a 1/3 pounder. Her burger more than fit the bun, and mine hung over the bun considerably. Both were nicely browned, and the first bite showed why this is a better burger than other fast food burgers… These are really, really good!
All in all, I would pick this burger over any other almost-fast-food chain I know of. I like that the different areas offer different style burgers, from chili burgers in Texas to a bleu cheese bacon burger in New Jersey, and lots of variations in between. The food is really well done, and the flavors are way above what I expect for a $20 meal for two of us (including a beer from Great Lakes Brewing, an Ohio brewer). If you’re close to a Smashburger, get there and have a great burger! I’d say to tell them I sent you, but they’d just look at you like you need help.
This post is tagged























I need to try smashburger. Thanks for pointing it out. 5 Guys is fairly new to Long Island and I eat there about once every two months or so. The burgers are good (maybe a bit better than good), but I agree that their fries rock. And they sure give you a lot of them! I also like the malt vinegar dipping sauce and the peanuts.
We just got a five guys near me… Good enough, no complaints, but like usual… Mine is better
Rumor has it that there might be a Five Guys in our area… but that Smashburger really does sound like something special (Smashburger guys — come here! We have great local brews here in Wisconsin!!!) .
Eric,
So far, New Jersey is the closest Smashburger, but I know they’re looking for more franchises to be set up. I do like Five Guys, too, but I’d pick Smashburger over it.
MYOTG,
Mine is better, too, I think, but for a fast food oriented place, both 5 Guys and Smashburger are pretty good. I will say that Five Guys puts great bacon on their bacon burgers.
lo,
Smashburger is in Minnesota, but not Wisconsin yet. With Wisconsin cheese, they could make a great, local 5 cheese Smashburger!
We don’t have a Smashburger yet but we did get a Five Guys. I haven’t tried it yet but my 21 y/o son loves them.
I will have to schlep up to Dayton one day and try Smashburger. It looks like it could be a decent choice.
As for Five Guys, I still have yet to figure out what all the hype is about. At least for me, when I order a burger, I would much rather have an actual burger than the heaping mess of congealed grease that Five Guys gives you. Then again, people love Skyline for some reason, so I guess quality and taste isn’t all that matters…
Chris,
The burgers themselves are ok at Five Guys. The toppings are good, and the bacon is great, but the fries are the best thing, I think.
Evan,
I’ve liked Five Guys, but wouldn’t stop there with a Smashburger close by. I am a Skyline fan, though; I think you either love Skyline or hate Skyline.